> Marx had to pretend to be anti-Jewish to widen the amount of people he could reach with his propaganda.
This is a laughable claim. He was also anti-Jewish in PRIVATE correspondence with Engels (the NON-Jewish co-founder of Communism), so was he "tricking" people by writing anti-Jewish stuff PRIVATELY? There is nothing public or private in which Marx says much of anything good about Jews and advocates for their disappearance as a group.
This is a GIANT cope for the obvious: Marx was anti-Jewish.
Not laughable as this behavior is standard among Jews and is prescribed in the Protocols & Talmud. The Jews, crypto-Jews & masons have also been caught red-handed before, faking history & playing false opposition. There is evidence Engels was Jewish as cited already & he was converted to communism by the Jewish Freemason Moses Hess. As also already noted, he identified himself as a Jew & had Jewish friends, also linked directly to the House of Rothschild. So much for your exaggerated claims. His autograph is also found in the Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 2 (1902) and is called a "Jewish celebrity". Arnold Leese said in his opposition to Jewish infiltration into Fascism, "Never mind what they say. Find out who they are." Being in apparent opposition to each other, is part of the strategy - Protocol 12. "Private" statements, I might add, that were published & spread around. And also, private statements, amongst whom - naive useful idiot gentiles? Conspiracies Against History and the Rites: [https://heritage-history.com/index.php?c=read&author=pinay&book=plot2&story=history] "The Jews have made the falsification of history into one of the great—perhaps the most important of all—secrets of their successes." Also note, relevant to the falsification of history, there is still many many volumes of material of/by Hess, Marx and Engels, that has never been released. It is being held mostly in Russia, but there is also some in England. All under lock & Key. Someday after much of it has passed through their main filters, it may get released. Related; British Jew and former rabbi, Dr. Lewis Browne (1897 - 1949) wrote: "Jewish histories rarely mention the name of this man, Karl Marx, though in his life and spirit he was far truer to the mission of Israel than most of those who were forever talking of it. ... Significantly enough, however, those who most fervidly talked of the Mission of the Jew, had little love for a Karl Marx who tried to live it. ... Reform rabbis still continued to tell the occupants of the pews that they were chosen for mighty works, that they were all messiahs. But those who really essayed those mighty works, those who were true messiahs, rarely sat in the pews to listen." Rabbi Avrom Shmulevich stated the fact that Marx utilized Kabbalah in his works, to control the masses. [paras 16-19 https://avrom.livejournal.com/701213.html] Jewish newspaper 'Haijut' 1928: “At the head of the Russian revolutionaries marched pupils of the Rabbinic school of Lidia. Jewry triumphed with OUR BROTHER MARX, who had the mandate for the fulfilment of the prophets.”
Marx's line had an 8-century unbroken line of Talmudic Rabbis! And again, on the cover up of history & falsification, the details of his maternal ancestors given in biographies are suspiciously, highly suspiciously scant. Karl Marx, through marriage, was closely related to the Rothschilds, the richest family on the planet, and this is undoubtedly the reason why his maternal ancestry is suppressed.
For additional denials that Marx was antisemitic, here it is argued that his "A World Without Jews" is essentially a 1955 anti-Zionist Soviet propaganda piece, cobbled together from different Marx's writings and the title was not Marx's own, but chosen by the Soviets 70+ years after his death, https://thekarlmarxblog.blogspot.com/2006/11/more-on-marx-and-his-alleged-anti.html
Is it a coincidence that these close Rabbinic & Banker families produced on one end, the Communist Manifesto, and on the other, the Balfour Declaration? Refer back to the genealogical study I would add. It is long proven Communism is a type of Jewish messianism, another form of Judaism, & even on finer points we see this to be true. For example, in 1841, commies wanted to abolish marriage, families & nationalize even human bodies (See The Courier [London], Nov. 20, 1841, p.1). "Whether a Gentile woman is married or not makes no difference, since as far as Jews are concerned the very concept of matrimony does not apply to Gentiles ('There is no matrimony for a heathen')." - Professor Israel Shahak.
In the New York Tribune, March 15, 1853 Marx wrote, in England, a lengthy article & said it was "absurd" that the exclusion of Jews from the House of Commons was still in effect. Is it hard to say he was a wicked two-faced person? I will leave that for others to decide.
Comment below deleted, edited in:
French masonic website: There were secret Freemasonic links between Peronism, MARX & Engels & Salvador Allende in Chile.
Elizabeth Dilling: Communism is Talmudism - Marx merely 'streamlined' Talmudism. The Socialist system he conceived is merely a practical means for a state dominated by a Jewish minority, to rule by absolute dictatorship over everything and everyone.
Yes, although Karl Marx's Jewish ancestry is usually admitted by all the dimwittedest of Jews or philosemities, you typically have to endure an attempt to portray Marx as an antisemite in the transparent agenda to distant the founder of communism from his Jewish brethren. Marx' letter to uncle Lion Philips affirms both as Jews. Germany in the 19th century had a public that was quite aware of the Jewish problem. Marx had to pretend to be anti-Jewish to widen the amount of people he could reach with his propaganda. All good conspirators make maneuvers to hide their tracks. The deceit of “atheistic” Communism meshes with another old trick designed to gain plausible deniability for Satan's tribe. "A racket as exceedingly hostile as Judaism to all outside it's camp must by necessity cover up it's true nature and intent." - Maurice Pinay
Fitzinfo on his website has an article detailing how the Jews are very well known to produce propaganda so as to create the illusion that Jewry and communism are not compatible as well. Further, Jewish author Bernard Lazare tells us that Karl Marx was indeed a Talmudist which gives positive command to lie to non-Jews for deceptive purposes. It has since been proven Marx comes from an established Rabbinic family & interesting that biographers of Marx have attempted to hide his maternal ancestry due to the revealing fact that he was very closely related to the Rothschild banking dynasty (Marx's great-grandfather, and Rothchild's grandfather; were brothers). Karl Marx and Lionel's uncle; James de Rothschild, had a mutual close friend, in the German Jewish poet Heinrich Heine.
Communism has been an instrument for giving Jews political power. And we're not even beginning to touch on the entire huge underwater layer of political cryptos that almost always remain outside the zone of goyish attention, and since these crypts are well financed and have enormous hidden support from the international, it is naturally very difficult for non-Jews to compete with them in the struggle for key political positions. The “abilities” of crypto-Jews in the struggle “for the masses” turn out to be incomparably higher. Considering also the fact that Communism would be a fundamental arm in this conspiracy for a long while, one can see the need to cover tracks from its inception, as also this pattern is found in the Protocols.
Czar Nicholas II stated in reference to the following letter, “I share entirely the opinions herein expressed”: "There is thus no room for doubt as to the close connexion of the Russian revolution with the Jewish question in general, and with the foreign Jewish organisations in particular, which connexion is already perfectly clear from the point of view of its fundamental principles, since the founders of the Socialist doctrine, Lassalle and Marx, who wield so great an influence on the present mind of the Russian University youth, were notoriously both of Jewish origin. Nor can it be in any way doubted that the practical direction of the Russian revolutionary movement is in Jewish hands.”
Karl Marx's Elite Connections (Genealogical Study): “So-called anti-capitalist Marx was directly related to and bankrolled by ELITE industrialists, financialists, and aristocrats... including, possibly, NATHAN MAYER ROTHSCHILD.” https://youtu.be/6Gus1D5I-5w
New International, Vol. 1 No. 5, December 1934: "We know that (Jewish Freemason) Moses Hess, the chief theoretician of the movement, converted Engels to communism, and Zlocisti, Hess’ biographer, claims that Hess was not without influence on Marx, too." -> Engels’ birth was German by location but, as to his race, authorities differ. Edwin D. Schoonmaker, for example, says: “the spiritual fathers of the New Russia” were “Marx and Engels, authors of the Communist Manifesto, both Jews and foreign Jews at that” (“Democracy and World Dominion”, Richard R. Smith, N. Y., p. 210). Prof. Shadwell says Engels was a Jew (“The Socialist Movement”, Philip Allan & Co., London, Vol I, p. 50). The London Spectator, in 1920, said of Marx and Engels “both German Jews”. Etc, etc. (Page 22, The Octopus)
I would also add this because you say the Protocols are a "weak source".
ex-Chabad Jew Eduard Hodos in his book Jewish Syndrome vol. 3, p. 48:
"One day the conversation turned to the "Protocols", which at that time I knew only by hearsay. Upon learning that I was not familiar with their contents, Itsik calmly took a well-published brochure in Russian from the bookcase. It was the "Protocols". Only the texts, without commentary...I will not describe my impressions of what I read. I will only say that the first thing I naturally asked was: who is the author? Itsik answered very briefly: "There was such a person...".
Michael Hagemeister, produced a text entitled The Protocols of the Elders of Zion: Between History and Fiction that although it does not endorse the authenticity of the protocols, nevertheless controverts the standard narrative. It shows that arguments put forth against the Protocols in the Berne trial relied on extremely unreliable information and witnesses. A notable quote from it is: [https://archive.ph/xcr5V] [https://www.jstor.org/stable/27669221]
Those who have made in-depth analyses of the subject have shown serious flaws in the standard forgery arguments - Peter Myers made an in-depth critique of Norman Cohn, the leading proponent of the “Protocols as fake” idea, which includes this gem:
“Cohn's arithmetic is incorrect. The word count of the parallel passages from the Protocols, as listed by Bernstein, is 4,361, while the word count of the Protocols is 26, 496. That is, the parallel passages comprise 16.45% of the Protocols; this is substantial but still less than one-sixth of the total. What Cohn especially omits to mention, is the Protocols' extensive coverage of the world finance system.” [https://mailstar.net/toolkit.html]
> Marx had to pretend to be anti-Jewish to widen the amount of people he could reach with his propaganda.
This is a laughable claim. He was also anti-Jewish in PRIVATE correspondence with Engels (the NON-Jewish co-founder of Communism), so was he "tricking" people by writing anti-Jewish stuff PRIVATELY? There is nothing public or private in which Marx says much of anything good about Jews and advocates for their disappearance as a group.
This is a GIANT cope for the obvious: Marx was anti-Jewish.
Not laughable as this behavior is standard among Jews and is prescribed in the Protocols & Talmud. The Jews, crypto-Jews & masons have also been caught red-handed before, faking history & playing false opposition. There is evidence Engels was Jewish as cited already & he was converted to communism by the Jewish Freemason Moses Hess. As also already noted, he identified himself as a Jew & had Jewish friends, also linked directly to the House of Rothschild. So much for your exaggerated claims. His autograph is also found in the Jewish Encyclopedia Vol. 2 (1902) and is called a "Jewish celebrity". Arnold Leese said in his opposition to Jewish infiltration into Fascism, "Never mind what they say. Find out who they are." Being in apparent opposition to each other, is part of the strategy - Protocol 12. "Private" statements, I might add, that were published & spread around. And also, private statements, amongst whom - naive useful idiot gentiles? Conspiracies Against History and the Rites: [https://heritage-history.com/index.php?c=read&author=pinay&book=plot2&story=history] "The Jews have made the falsification of history into one of the great—perhaps the most important of all—secrets of their successes." Also note, relevant to the falsification of history, there is still many many volumes of material of/by Hess, Marx and Engels, that has never been released. It is being held mostly in Russia, but there is also some in England. All under lock & Key. Someday after much of it has passed through their main filters, it may get released. Related; British Jew and former rabbi, Dr. Lewis Browne (1897 - 1949) wrote: "Jewish histories rarely mention the name of this man, Karl Marx, though in his life and spirit he was far truer to the mission of Israel than most of those who were forever talking of it. ... Significantly enough, however, those who most fervidly talked of the Mission of the Jew, had little love for a Karl Marx who tried to live it. ... Reform rabbis still continued to tell the occupants of the pews that they were chosen for mighty works, that they were all messiahs. But those who really essayed those mighty works, those who were true messiahs, rarely sat in the pews to listen." Rabbi Avrom Shmulevich stated the fact that Marx utilized Kabbalah in his works, to control the masses. [paras 16-19 https://avrom.livejournal.com/701213.html] Jewish newspaper 'Haijut' 1928: “At the head of the Russian revolutionaries marched pupils of the Rabbinic school of Lidia. Jewry triumphed with OUR BROTHER MARX, who had the mandate for the fulfilment of the prophets.”
Marx's line had an 8-century unbroken line of Talmudic Rabbis! And again, on the cover up of history & falsification, the details of his maternal ancestors given in biographies are suspiciously, highly suspiciously scant. Karl Marx, through marriage, was closely related to the Rothschilds, the richest family on the planet, and this is undoubtedly the reason why his maternal ancestry is suppressed.
For additional denials that Marx was antisemitic, here it is argued that his "A World Without Jews" is essentially a 1955 anti-Zionist Soviet propaganda piece, cobbled together from different Marx's writings and the title was not Marx's own, but chosen by the Soviets 70+ years after his death, https://thekarlmarxblog.blogspot.com/2006/11/more-on-marx-and-his-alleged-anti.html
Is it a coincidence that these close Rabbinic & Banker families produced on one end, the Communist Manifesto, and on the other, the Balfour Declaration? Refer back to the genealogical study I would add. It is long proven Communism is a type of Jewish messianism, another form of Judaism, & even on finer points we see this to be true. For example, in 1841, commies wanted to abolish marriage, families & nationalize even human bodies (See The Courier [London], Nov. 20, 1841, p.1). "Whether a Gentile woman is married or not makes no difference, since as far as Jews are concerned the very concept of matrimony does not apply to Gentiles ('There is no matrimony for a heathen')." - Professor Israel Shahak.
In the New York Tribune, March 15, 1853 Marx wrote, in England, a lengthy article & said it was "absurd" that the exclusion of Jews from the House of Commons was still in effect. Is it hard to say he was a wicked two-faced person? I will leave that for others to decide.
Comment below deleted, edited in:
French masonic website: There were secret Freemasonic links between Peronism, MARX & Engels & Salvador Allende in Chile.
para 2 https://450.fm/2024/11/25/le-maire-de-moreno-mariel-fernandez-et-la-franc-maconnerie/
P2 lodge Head Licio Gelli: Perón was initiated into Freemasonry.
https://web.archive.org/web/20130317185343/http://www.perfil.com/contenidos/2008/08/31/noticia_0019.html
Elizabeth Dilling: Communism is Talmudism - Marx merely 'streamlined' Talmudism. The Socialist system he conceived is merely a practical means for a state dominated by a Jewish minority, to rule by absolute dictatorship over everything and everyone.
http://come-and-hear.com/dilling/chapt11.html
Yes, although Karl Marx's Jewish ancestry is usually admitted by all the dimwittedest of Jews or philosemities, you typically have to endure an attempt to portray Marx as an antisemite in the transparent agenda to distant the founder of communism from his Jewish brethren. Marx' letter to uncle Lion Philips affirms both as Jews. Germany in the 19th century had a public that was quite aware of the Jewish problem. Marx had to pretend to be anti-Jewish to widen the amount of people he could reach with his propaganda. All good conspirators make maneuvers to hide their tracks. The deceit of “atheistic” Communism meshes with another old trick designed to gain plausible deniability for Satan's tribe. "A racket as exceedingly hostile as Judaism to all outside it's camp must by necessity cover up it's true nature and intent." - Maurice Pinay
Fitzinfo on his website has an article detailing how the Jews are very well known to produce propaganda so as to create the illusion that Jewry and communism are not compatible as well. Further, Jewish author Bernard Lazare tells us that Karl Marx was indeed a Talmudist which gives positive command to lie to non-Jews for deceptive purposes. It has since been proven Marx comes from an established Rabbinic family & interesting that biographers of Marx have attempted to hide his maternal ancestry due to the revealing fact that he was very closely related to the Rothschild banking dynasty (Marx's great-grandfather, and Rothchild's grandfather; were brothers). Karl Marx and Lionel's uncle; James de Rothschild, had a mutual close friend, in the German Jewish poet Heinrich Heine.
Communism has been an instrument for giving Jews political power. And we're not even beginning to touch on the entire huge underwater layer of political cryptos that almost always remain outside the zone of goyish attention, and since these crypts are well financed and have enormous hidden support from the international, it is naturally very difficult for non-Jews to compete with them in the struggle for key political positions. The “abilities” of crypto-Jews in the struggle “for the masses” turn out to be incomparably higher. Considering also the fact that Communism would be a fundamental arm in this conspiracy for a long while, one can see the need to cover tracks from its inception, as also this pattern is found in the Protocols.
Czar Nicholas II stated in reference to the following letter, “I share entirely the opinions herein expressed”: "There is thus no room for doubt as to the close connexion of the Russian revolution with the Jewish question in general, and with the foreign Jewish organisations in particular, which connexion is already perfectly clear from the point of view of its fundamental principles, since the founders of the Socialist doctrine, Lassalle and Marx, who wield so great an influence on the present mind of the Russian University youth, were notoriously both of Jewish origin. Nor can it be in any way doubted that the practical direction of the Russian revolutionary movement is in Jewish hands.”
https://www.gutenberg.org/files/31385/31385-h/31385-h.htm#Page_57
Karl Marx's Elite Connections (Genealogical Study): “So-called anti-capitalist Marx was directly related to and bankrolled by ELITE industrialists, financialists, and aristocrats... including, possibly, NATHAN MAYER ROTHSCHILD.” https://youtu.be/6Gus1D5I-5w
New International, Vol. 1 No. 5, December 1934: "We know that (Jewish Freemason) Moses Hess, the chief theoretician of the movement, converted Engels to communism, and Zlocisti, Hess’ biographer, claims that Hess was not without influence on Marx, too." -> Engels’ birth was German by location but, as to his race, authorities differ. Edwin D. Schoonmaker, for example, says: “the spiritual fathers of the New Russia” were “Marx and Engels, authors of the Communist Manifesto, both Jews and foreign Jews at that” (“Democracy and World Dominion”, Richard R. Smith, N. Y., p. 210). Prof. Shadwell says Engels was a Jew (“The Socialist Movement”, Philip Allan & Co., London, Vol I, p. 50). The London Spectator, in 1920, said of Marx and Engels “both German Jews”. Etc, etc. (Page 22, The Octopus)
I would also add this because you say the Protocols are a "weak source".
ex-Chabad Jew Eduard Hodos in his book Jewish Syndrome vol. 3, p. 48:
"One day the conversation turned to the "Protocols", which at that time I knew only by hearsay. Upon learning that I was not familiar with their contents, Itsik calmly took a well-published brochure in Russian from the bookcase. It was the "Protocols". Only the texts, without commentary...I will not describe my impressions of what I read. I will only say that the first thing I naturally asked was: who is the author? Itsik answered very briefly: "There was such a person...".
Michael Hagemeister, produced a text entitled The Protocols of the Elders of Zion: Between History and Fiction that although it does not endorse the authenticity of the protocols, nevertheless controverts the standard narrative. It shows that arguments put forth against the Protocols in the Berne trial relied on extremely unreliable information and witnesses. A notable quote from it is: [https://archive.ph/xcr5V] [https://www.jstor.org/stable/27669221]
Those who have made in-depth analyses of the subject have shown serious flaws in the standard forgery arguments - Peter Myers made an in-depth critique of Norman Cohn, the leading proponent of the “Protocols as fake” idea, which includes this gem:
“Cohn's arithmetic is incorrect. The word count of the parallel passages from the Protocols, as listed by Bernstein, is 4,361, while the word count of the Protocols is 26, 496. That is, the parallel passages comprise 16.45% of the Protocols; this is substantial but still less than one-sixth of the total. What Cohn especially omits to mention, is the Protocols' extensive coverage of the world finance system.” [https://mailstar.net/toolkit.html]
Of value is Leslie Fry's book Waters Flowing Eastward, a detailed analysis of the Protocols: https://web.archive.org/web/20130406012657/http://ia600605.us.archive.org/17/items/WatersFlowingEastward_307/1-watersFlowingEastward.pdf
Common-Sense magazine 1957 page 2 tells how Kerensky (Jew & mason), key in the Feb 1917 revolution, ordered every copy of the Protocols of Zion to be burnt [https://fau.digital.flvc.org/islandora/object/fau%3A32504/datastream/OBJ/view]